Windy City Media Group Frontpage News
Celebrating 30 Years of Gay Lesbian Bisexual and Trans News
home search facebook twitter
Gay News Sponsor Windy City Times 2015-04-22
DOWNLOAD ISSUE
About WCMG Publications News Index  Entertainment Features Bars & Clubs Calendar Videos Advertisers OUT! Guide    Marriage

Sponsor

  WINDY CITY TIMES

IDHR dismissal of trans complaint raises questions
by Kate Sosin, Windy City Times
2012-08-29

facebook twitter pin it del.icio.us stumble upon digg google +1 reddit email


In a stunning blow to transgender-rights advocates, the Illinois Department of Human Rights (IDHR) has thrown out a complaint by a transgender woman barred from using the women's restroom at work, despite having state ID indicating she is female.

Meggan Sommerville, a 14-year employee of Hobby Lobby, filed a complaint against her employer last year after the chain admittedly refused her access to the women's room.

The complaint argued that Hobby Lobby violated the Illinois Human Rights Act by denying her full and equal enjoyment of their services.

Sommerville had transitioned from living as male to female at the time and had obtained a driver's license indicating that she is female.

Transgender advocates have long held that the Illinois Human Rights Act, which grants equal access to public accommodations regardless of gender identity or sexual orientation, protected transgender people in public restrooms, especially if they had obtained state IDs indicating their new gender identity.

"IDHR basically showed an absolute ignorance," said Sommerville, noting that the IDHR decision incorrectly refers to her being transgender as a "sexual identity."

According to Sommerville, she remains banned from using the women's room at her Aurora store.

The dismissal confirms that Hobby Lobby personnel instructed Sommerville to use the men's room because she "still possessed his (sic) male anatomy."

A Hobby Lobby spokesperson said the company does not comment on pending legal matters.

In June, IDHR dismissed Sommerville's case for lack of evidence. Sommerville learned of the ruling in late July through Betty Tsamis, a well-known lesbian attorney who had been working on the case (Sommerville said Tsamis is no longer representing her because the two had a disagreement).

According to the IDHR dismissal, the complaint was thrown out because at the time of her conversations with managers on the issue, Sommerville was still in the process of transitioning from male to female. It also says, her "physical anatomy was that of a male," and she had failed to provide her managers with legal precedent that would prove the store was required to let her use the women's room.

The document further notes that Sommerville had previously agreed to use the men's room, a statement that Sommerville contends is false.

Finally, the dismissal references a series of incidents in which Sommerville was accused of sexual harassment for side-hugging, following and making physical contact with a co-worker in 2006. Sommerville was relocated to another Hobby Lobby store over the allegation, but a formal police complaint was never filed. Sommerville denied the allegations of sexual harassment.

Sommerville said she worries for her safety and for the image of the store when she uses a male bathroom shared by customers.

"I look over my shoulder every time I need to use the restroom," she said. She has to wait, she said, until no one is in or around the bathroom before going.

Sommerville's anxieties are not uncommon among transgender people. Transgender women in particular face harassment in large numbers regardless of the gendered bathroom they choose.

Last year, Chrissy Lee Polis—a transgender woman who used a female restroom in a Baltimore, Md., McDonald's—made headlines when she was beaten by two other women while employees filmed the attack.

While Polis was using the women's room at the time, many advocates have argued that trans women face a greater risk of violence in men's rooms.

Sommerville's case could prove significant for other transgender Illinoisans, many of whom use the bathroom that corresponds with their updated IDs, despite not having had genital surgery.

Such surgeries are often costly, are rarely covered by insurance providers and are not always desired by trans people.

Transgender people can change the gender markers on their state IDs and on their U.S. passports without proof of genital surgery.

This year, the American Civil Liberties Union won a court ruling on behalf of three trans people who wanted new Illinois birth certificates but had not undergone genital surgery.

Just one transgender person is known to have won a discrimination case under the Illinois Human Rights Act. Vanessa Fitzsimmons, a taxi driver, successfully sued her former employer for discrimination last year.

"Nobody has tested this [bathroom issue]," Sommerville noted. "This could have been a landmark case."

But despite lack of precedence under the Illinois Human Rights Act, trans advocates have long advised that IDs were more than sufficient proof of the right to use the bathroom marked with their preferred gender.

"This just seems like a slam dunk case of discrimination," said Christina Kahrl, a trans advocate and board member of Equality Illinois. "They are betraying the spirit of the Illinois Human Rights Ordinance."

Kahrl argued that the dismissal sends a message that rights are "economically determined" by who can afford gender-related surgeries and who cannot.

She also worries that the dismissal has set a precedent under which similar cases of alleged discrimination could be thrown out.

"A non-ruling doesn't mean they will rule incorrectly on something in the future, but it does create uncertainty on something that should be absolutely clear," she said.

Kahrl said that Equality Illinois would be taking action on the dismissal, but declined to provide further details. She added that she believes transgender people should continue to use the bathrooms that they have been using.

Equality Illinois was instrumental in the 2005 inclusion of gender identity protections in the Human Rights Act.

Aiding in the effort at that time was Rick Garcia, policy advisor of The Civil Rights Agenda (TCRA), and a longtime LGBT-rights activist. Garcia has worked closely with IDHR for years, he said, even conducting a training on trans issues for IDHR with trans advocate June LaTrobe.

"They have been really good about understanding trans issues," said Garcia. "From what I understand of this case, this was an aberration."

Garcia said he urged Sommerville to ask for a review of the case.

Mike Claffey, a spokesperson for IDHR, said IDHR cannot comment on cases still in the request for review period. "But anybody who is not satisfied with the outcome of their complaint has an avenue of appeal," he said.

Sommerville has until Sept. 24-25 to appeal the two charges listed in her initial complaint. She could also take her case to the circuit court.

Those avenues, however, may not be options for Sommerville. She is behind on rent, she said, and can't afford the cost of an attorney she may need to pursue either route.

Sommerville can likely request a review at IDHR at no cost and without the help of an attorney. If her case makes it past that process, however, she will likely need legal assistance.

Disclosure: This reporter participated in an unrelated educational project around transgender people and restrooms in Illinois that referenced the Illinois Human Rights Act.

First day online coverage appeared Aug. 23, 2012, under the headline: "IDHR dismissal of trans complaint raises questions, by Kate Sosin, Windy City Times


facebook twitter pin it del.icio.us stumble upon digg google +1 reddit email




Windy City Media Group does not approve or necessarily agree with the views posted below.
Please do not post letters to the editor here. Please also be civil in your dialogue.
If you need to be mean, just know that the longer you stay on this page, the more you help us.


  ARTICLES YOU MIGHT LIKE

Jenner comes out as trans in historic interview 2015-04-24
'Striking' increase in Americans who know trans people 2015-04-23
The Baton becomes 'Transformative' 2015-04-22
National Finance Company sued for firing transgender employee 2015-04-16
Talk show on lives of transgender individuals casting April 18 2015-04-15
Life at 80: Renee Richards on and off the tennis court 2015-04-15
Briefs: Trans soldier; Obama against conversion therapy: blood donation 2015-04-14
Florida eye clinic to pay $150,000 in trans/sex discrimination case 2015-04-13
Southern Poverty Law Center statement on Ashley Diamond case 2015-04-10
EEOC to ensure restroom access for transgender employees 2015-04-08
Transforming Gender: The Edge of the Knife 2015-04-08
Center marks ITQI Day of Visibility 2015-04-08
National: Jeb Bush; Dan Savage; White House trans briefing 2015-04-07
Film about transgender teacher in Hawaii on PBS May 4 2015-04-06
Open group letter on 2015 violence against LGBTQs, trans women of color 2015-04-02
Upcoming: Music for Matthew; Trans, adult, queer film events; Lollapalooza 2015-04-01
TELEVISION 'New Girls on the Block' trans-focused series examines trans issues 2015-03-31
Nat'l roundup: Trans study; Indiana fallout; Supreme Ct. argument 2015-03-31
Camp Aranu'tiq: A place for transgender and gender-variant youth 2015-03-31
Workshops look at legal system's treatment of trans individuals 2015-03-31
Report: Military families suffer From transgender ban 2015-03-31
Texas prison agrees to put Lambda transgender client in safekeeping 2015-03-30
DoJ moves against university for discriminating against trans employee 2015-03-30
Trans 100 celebrated in Chicago 2015-03-30
Windy City Times' writer nominated for Lisagor award 2015-03-27
Williams Institute to do first-of-its-kind study of transgender population 2015-03-25
Lake View voice lab helps trans clients find their voices 2015-03-25
N.C. trans activist, 18, commits suicide 2015-03-24
GLAAD honors Kerry Washington, 'Transparent' 2015-03-24
Transgender community members demonstrate, demand recognition 2015-03-24
DePaul forum looks at 19th-century transgender labor 2015-03-18
Upcoming: UChicago LGBTQ; Creating Change; Latin@ week; Trans pres appointee 2015-03-17
World: Lesbian tennis player; restroom situation; IKEA website 2015-03-17
Navy's top enlisted sailor supports open service by transgender troops 2015-03-13
Jan. 9 murder of Papi Edwards confirmed as trans-related 2015-03-11
Davis 'extremely proud' of time at Transgender Law Center 2015-03-11
Transformative Justice Law Project holds open house 2015-03-11
National roundup: Supreme Court and marriage; trans-inmate motion 2015-03-10
CA won't do business with companies discriminating against trans employees 2015-03-06
Army takes steps to protect transgender troops 2015-03-06
 



Copyright © 2015 Windy City Media Group. All rights reserved.
Reprint by permission only. PDFs for back issues are downloadable from
our online archives. Single copies of back issues in print form are
available for $4 per issue, older than one month for $6 if available,
by check to the mailing address listed below.

Return postage must accompany all manuscripts, drawings, and
photographs submitted if they are to be returned, and no
responsibility may be assumed for unsolicited materials.
All rights to letters, art and photos sent to Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago
Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication) will be treated
as unconditionally assigned for publication purposes and as such,
subject to editing and comment. The opinions expressed by the
columnists, cartoonists, letter writers, and commentators are
their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay,
Lesbian, Bisexual and Transegender News and Feature Publication).

The appearance of a name, image or photo of a person or group in
Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times
(a Chicago Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender News and Feature
Publication) does not indicate the sexual orientation of such
individuals or groups. While we encourage readers to support the
advertisers who make this newspaper possible, Nightspots (Chicago
GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay, Lesbian
News and Feature Publication) cannot accept responsibility for
any advertising claims or promotions.

 

 

 

TRENDINGBREAKINGPHOTOS

Sponsor
Sponsor
Sponsor
Sponsor
Sponsor
Sponsor


 

Sponsor


Sponsor

About WCMG Publications News Index  Entertainment Features Bars & Clubs Calendar Videos Advertisers OUT! Guide    Marriage



About WCMG      Contact Us      Online Front  Page      Windy City  Times      Nightspots      OUT! Guide     
Identity      BLACKlines      En La Vida      Archives      Subscriptions      Distribution      Windy City Queercast     
Queercast Archives      Advertising  Rates      Deadlines      Advanced Search     
Press  Releases      Event Photos      Join WCMG  Email List      Email Blast     
Upcoming Events      Todays Events      Ongoing Events      Post an Event      Bar Guide      Community Groups      In Memoriam      Outguide Categories      Outguide Advertisers      Search Outguide      Travel      Dining Out      Blogs      Spotlight  Video     
Classifieds      Real Estate      Place a  Classified     

Windy City Media Group produces Windy City Queercast, & publishes Windy City Times,
The Weekly Voice of the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Trans Community,
Nightspots, Out! Resource Guide, and Identity.
5315 N. Clark St. #192, Chicago, IL 60640-2113 • PH (773) 871-7610 • FAX (773) 871-7609.